Red Herring
A rare fish caught in the waters of Tristram, with a hidden achievement and a reference to one of Diablo's oldest mysteries.
The Red Herring
The Red Herring is a rare fish introduced in Diablo IV Season 15 as part of the Lord of Hatred fishing content.
Its description reads:
"A rare fish found in Khanduras."
Unlike many of Diablo IV's mysterious fishing collectibles, the Red Herring has a known catch location.
It can be obtained by fishing in the waters of Tristram, the legendary town from the original Diablo.
Catching it also completes a hidden achievement bearing the same name.
The fish's name and flavor text reference an old conversation with Deckard Cain involving Adria's Black Mushroom.
Where to Catch the Red Herring
Location: Tristram, Khanduras
Method: Fishing
Rarity: Rare
The Red Herring is caught directly from the water in Tristram.
To obtain it:
- Travel to Tristram.
- Locate the fishable water in town.
- Cast your fishing line into the water.
- Continue fishing until you catch the Red Herring.
The item is a rare fishing catch, so it may take multiple attempts before appearing.
Its exact catch rate has not been established.
Hidden Red Herring Achievement
Catching the Red Herring completes a hidden achievement also named Red Herring.
The achievement description reads:
"Collect this Rare fish found in Khanduras."
The achievement is associated specifically with this item, rather than with the general fishing collection.
This makes the Red Herring both a collectible and a small hidden achievement for players exploring Tristram.
The Diablo I Connection
The Red Herring is a reference to dialogue from the original Diablo, involving Deckard Cain and Adria's mysterious Black Mushroom.
During the Black Mushroom quest, the player searches for a special mushroom requested by Adria the Witch.
When questioned about the mushroom, Deckard Cain responds:
"I know as much about Black Mushrooms as I do about Red Herrings."
The line is a joke built around the expression red herring, which describes a misleading clue or distraction from the actual solution to a mystery.
Bringing an actual Red Herring into Diablo IV, particularly in Tristram, is a fitting reference to the original game.
Is the Fish Part of Another Secret?
The fish's association with the Black Mushroom raises an interesting possibility.
Could the Red Herring have another use connected to Diablo IV's Black Mushroom mysteries?
There is currently no confirmed quest interaction, crafting recipe, or additional reward involving the fish.
Its confirmed purpose is the hidden achievement.
Its name may simply be an intentional joke, warning players not to mistake every unusual collectible for a larger secret.
For more background, see the Season 15 Black Mushroom mystery.
What the Game Files Reveal
The Red Herring has its own item and hidden achievement records.
| Property | Value |
|---|---|
| Name | Red Herring |
| Internal ID | X2_Fish_Tristram_Rare |
| Item SNO | 2680715 |
| Achievement SNO | 2680750 |
| Rarity | Rare |
| Location | Tristram, Khanduras |
| Sell value | 1,000 gold |
| Introduced | Patch 3.2.1 |
| Season requirement | None |
Additional Details
- The
X2_prefix identifies the item as part of the Lord of Hatred expansion content. - Its item data places it in the Tristram fishing collection.
- The fish reuses a small demonic fish model associated with Hawezar.
- Its hidden achievement completes when the Rare fish is collected.
- The item has no explicit season requirement.
Although the client game files do not contain the complete fishing drop tables, the item's catch location is established through in-game discovery.